May 26, 2024


Passion For Business

Telehealth reimbursement parity spurs insurer concerns of overutilization

(Photo: Geber86/Getty Images)(Picture: Geber86/Getty Images)

Telehealth has been through a radical transformation through the class of the COVID-19 pandemic. In a little extra than fourteen months, it has advanced from a niche supplying that authorized patients to see clinicians while retaining socially distant to starting to be a significant portion of the future of health care. 

Telehealth was a feasible assistance in advance of the pandemic, but it was reimbursed at reduced charges than in-place of work visits. There have been geographical restrictions that put stringent parameters on where a patient could access digital health care expert services – as perfectly as where a clinician could treat them. It was, in a word, restricted.

Now, with a lot of of those restrictions lifted at minimum briefly, hospitals, insurers and patients are starting up to see some of the downstream consequences, and all get-togethers are asking yourself how digital care will appear, and what it will be like, when the pandemic is at last in the rearview mirror. 

Already the marketplace is viewing utilization change as a outcome, and payment parity is on both of those payers’ and providers’ minds. 

THE Reward OF Digital BEHAVIORAL Overall health

Dr. William Lopez, countrywide director for digital care at main insurance company Cigna, claimed digital care presented a pathway for its customers to request care and was something the business actively inspired, especially for psychological well being expert services. In advance of the pandemic, he claimed, digital visits manufactured up just in excess of one% of all expert place of work visits that authorized for them. Today, they make up approximately 25%. This shift is envisioned to continue, with a new survey finding that 75% of Us citizens see a future of health care at household. 

“Digital care has performed a especially significant function in addressing psychological well being through the pandemic,” claimed Lopez. “There was also a sharp enhance in the use of outpatient behavioral well being expert services, which rose by 27% in comparison to pre-pandemic levels. In point, the growth of digital well being has place behavioral care in just access of extra people, with in excess of sixty% of behavioral well being customers conducting digital classes. Presented the ease, advantage and accessibility of digital care – and the more privacy that digital behavioral health care delivers – we hope digital care to stay in high demand from customers publish-pandemic.”

Presented patients’ elevated ease and comfort with digital consultations, extra people than at any time are requesting access to telehealth. That, claimed Lopez, could create a threat of overutilization publish-pandemic, but is on Cigna’s radar and is a thought as the insurance company proceeds to evolve its reimbursement and positive aspects approaches.


The opportunity for overutilization and its economical costs is a very long-term problem for Cigna and for all insurers. 

There is an escalating get in touch with for some of telehealth’s flexibilities, which have been sophisticated in the CARES Act, to continue on a everlasting foundation, and this could have the downstream outcome of costing non-public insurance policy providers extra revenue.

Compensation for suppliers is generally based on things these kinds of as the time invested with the patient or how complicated and risky the test is to execute. The CARES Act mandates that telehealth visits be paid out for at the exact same charge as in-person visits for those insured by Medicare. Most non-public insurers followed fit, having to pay suppliers for telehealth visits at the exact same charge as in-person expert services.

Overall health insurers want to redefine health care supplier condition licensing demands, in accordance to Reuters. They also question to be capable to style and design their positive aspects and offerings based on the wants of their customers.

Insurers are inquiring policymakers for reimbursement adaptability and authorization to use utilization management tools. The quantities spotlight the rationale powering this request: In March 2020, non-public insurance company claims for telehealth rose extra than four,000% in comparison to the calendar year prior, increasing from .seventeen% to seven.52%. 

THE Monetary Outcome

According to The Wall Road Journal, some significant insurers are pulling back some of their telehealth coverage for non-COVID-19-relevant issues. UnitedHealthcare, for illustration, rolled back policies last slide that waived copays and other charges for non-coronavirus appointments. Anthem BlueCross BlueShield prolonged coverage by the conclusion of 2020, but only the 1st two classes are totally free for the purchaser.

Including to the complication is that unique insurance policy options and condition-funded Medicaid options have unique principles for which treatments they go over. That indicates some patients are having to pay extra, and costs are starting to be puzzling. People may perhaps conclusion up with a shock monthly bill, or delay care altogether thanks to price tag.

Still, insurers usually are not emotion the pinch rather still. Most are just anticipating it. If just about anything, gains among the main insurers are mainly up. This was backed up by a Kaiser Family members Foundation investigation launched this month displaying that, in 2020 at minimum, gross margins have been greater and professional medical reduction ratios have been reduced than in 2019. Reduction ratios in the Medicaid MCO sector have been reduced in 2020 than in 2019 or 2018.

Medicare Gain insurers that slide quick of needed reduction ratio demands for many many years encounter more penalties, which includes the possibility of remaining terminated. To keep away from this threat, KFF anticipates that some MA insurers with reduction ratios under eighty five% may perhaps get the option to offer new or extra generous excess positive aspects, these kinds of as gymnasium memberships and dental or eyesight positive aspects, which are well known and assistance to attract new enrollees. 

For Medicaid managed care organizations, supplied the options that states have to modify payments and threat-sharing agreements through the pandemic, options may perhaps not be left with unforeseen surpluses, or fall short to access their state’s professional medical reduction ratio threshold this calendar year.

Waiving out-of-pocket costs for telehealth and COVID-19-relevant expert services had the outcome of escalating professional medical reduction ratios and reducing margins. An earlier investigation published on the Peterson-Kaiser Overall health Program Tracker identified that approximately ninety% of enrollees in the individual and totally-insured group marketplaces have been in a prepare that waived price tag-sharing for COVID-19 treatment at some level through the pandemic. About forty% of enrollees in these marketplaces have been in options that presented some form of high quality credit score or reduction in 2020. 

Very affordable Care Act professional medical reduction ratio rebates in 2021 are envisioned to full in the billions of bucks for a third consecutive calendar year. Specific and group sector insurers hope to spend out $ billion in rebates to buyers this slide based on their economical functionality in 2020, 2019 and 2018. Most of these rebates – an believed $one.five billion – are accounted for by individual sector insurers.

What all that indicates is that the pandemic’s outcome on well being paying out and insurers’ economical functionality in 2021 remains unsure. Utilization has rebounded considering that the peak of the pandemic, and could increase further more if pent-up demand from customers spurs extra patients to go after expert services.

Cigna, for its portion, has weathered the uncertainty gracefully up to this level, beating economical anticipations through the 1st quarter of 2021 with a $one.2 billion financial gain. Its total income arrived at $41 billion through the quarter, pushed in significant portion by its Evernorth well being expert services device, which contains pharmacy advantage supervisor Categorical Scripts. The device posted a thirteen% enhance in income from the exact same time last calendar year.

In its earnings report, Cigna projected 2021 adjusted income to be at minimum $166 billion, while the outlook for consolidated adjusted cash flow from operations is at minimum $seven billion. The projections factor in opportunity issues from the pandemic.

“As we appear at the effect of the COVID-19 ecosystem, adoption has been significantly accelerated, and this is specially genuine with telehealth by the use of technological innovation to allow coordinated care that can be fulfilled in the household,” claimed Lopez. “We anticipate ongoing adoption and growth, not just from an affordability standpoint, but from a personalization standpoint.

“Publish-pandemic, we will continue to acquire sturdy clinical top quality applications that ensure equivalent or superior outcomes from digital care as in comparison to equivalent in-person care.”


With all of these complexities, must payment parity for telehealth expert services continue? The response is a complicated just one.

A new Overall health Affairs investigation examined both of those sides of the concern, and sensible arguments from payment parity exist. Telehealth may perhaps call for less clinical work than an in-person visit, for illustration, and may perhaps also supply less value. Importantly, telehealth may perhaps also have a greater opportunity for overuse.

Yet inspite of that problem, you can find little persuasive evidence suggesting that continuing payment parity right after the conclusion of the pandemic will lead to runaway health care paying out. In an investigation of Blue Cross Blue Defend of Michigan claims from January by Oct 2020, telehealth rose from zero to about half of all outpatient visits at the commence of the pandemic, but it settled at about 21% by Oct. 

Whilst telehealth use is now twenty moments greater than it was prior to the pandemic, the full quantity of weekly outpatient visits has not exceeded pre-pandemic levels. In other phrases, telehealth has served as a substitute for in-person care.

Whilst fraud, abuse and overuse are valid fears, they can be mitigated by aligning reimbursement for video and audio-only visits with the exact same evaluation and management billing and documentation standards needed for in-person visits, Overall health Affairs identified. CMS can use different modifier codes for video-based and audio-only telehealth to check and examine outliers for overuse and abuse.

The suggestion for professional insurers is to wait around for sufficient knowledge to properly estimate telehealth’s effect on access, costs and top quality. In the meantime, they must continue payment parity right after the public well being unexpected emergency to permit the technological innovation space to flourish in a extra “standard” ecosystem, in accordance to Overall health Affairs. In quick, telehealth has the opportunity to cut down total health care paying out and increase access and the patient experience. 

Lopez claimed Cigna remains fully commited.

“All over the pandemic, we have manufactured certain all suppliers are reimbursed for digital care at the exact same charges as in-person visits, and we have ongoing that dedication as the place recovers from the pandemic,” he claimed. “This coverage guarantees everlasting coverage of digital care, offering customers ongoing access to their health practitioner in a digital location and coverage for popular expert services performed just about. It will also permit customers to pick out a new supplier and to be found just about for new patient visits.

“We continue to appraise the appropriate reimbursement degree for digital (care) publish-pandemic, getting into account all of our stakeholders,” he claimed.

HOW WE Received Right here

In advance of the coronavirus floor the environment to a halt, telehealth was generally employed in rural settings, and was found as a way to deliver access to those who lacked transportation or lived much absent from the nearest healthcare facility.

Flash forward to December 2020, when then Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Providers Administrator Seema Verma claimed Congressional action was required to retain telehealth from reverting to a rural advantage. That exact same month, CMS issued the 2021 Medicare medical doctor payment plan ultimate rule and interim ultimate rule, which clarified which telehealth expert services would be coated by Medicare, at minimum until the conclusion of the calendar year of the public well being unexpected emergency, on a everlasting or short-term foundation.

All through the public well being unexpected emergency, CMS lifted the geographic restriction that beneficiaries will have to be found in a rural space, and permitted beneficiaries to acquire telehealth expert services from their houses. It also authorized a broader variety of suppliers to supply telehealth expert services, these kinds of as bodily therapists, occupational therapists and speech-language pathologists.

The company also extra coverage and payment for audio-only types of telehealth, enabled rural well being centers to provide as qualified distant websites, and expanded Medicare telehealth coverage to extra than 100 more expert services.

These alterations have been set to expire right after the conclusion of the public well being unexpected emergency, but teams these kinds of as the Medicare Payment Advisory Fee suggested to prolong telehealth flexibilities for a restricted time so that extra evidence could be gathered about its effect on access, utilization, top quality and paying out.

All through just one or two many years of evidence accumulating, Medicare must briefly spend for specified telehealth expert services, regardless of a provider’s locale, and CMS must continue to go over freshly-coated telehealth expert services and some audio-only care, MedPAC claimed in March.

Twitter: @JELagasse
Electronic mail the author: [email protected]